Quick Home Search


Molly is a top-notch realtor! She helped us every step of the way to find our perfect property. She is smart, patient, knowledgeable, and professional. We would certainly use her again, and would recommend her to anyone who wants to buy or sell a home.

Geoff & Krista

Molly's great. We've worked with her through three transactions, both buying and selling, and couldn't be happier. She knows CB real estate inside and out. When it comes to buying, she listens and is very good at zeroing in on what sort of property will work for you, and as far as I can tell has limitless patience for indecisive clients (which we totally are). Whether buying or selling, she's a deft negotiator. And she's also a lot of fun to drive around and look at properties with. We can't recommend her highly enough. We'll be working with her on any future real estate transactions in CB.

Rob Z

Working with Molly was an outstanding experience. Molly understood our quirky interests and helped us find the ideal piece of real estate. Then, she expertly guided us through the process to closing, including talking us down from few ledges. We are delighted to have worked with Molly and look forward to future adventures in CB real estate

Kate & Matt

We recently sold our condo with the help of Molly Eldridge of Red Lady Realty. She did a great job representing our interests in a timely way, doing everything she could to expedite a complicated sale. She is extremely knowledgeable and definitely willing to go the extra mile to assure that any issues are quickly resolved. I highly recommend Molly as your Realtor in buying or selling property in Crested Butte.

K & C Duncan

She found exactly what we were looking for and we purchased the home. Our offer was submitted promptly and negotiations were quick and accurate. Molly was very helpful during the due diligence as we are not Colorado residents.

Roger & Darcie

Molly is wonderful! She is very "down to Earth" and incredibley knowledgeable of the local market. Her mailers/emails are very informative, and demonstrate her grasp of what's happening here in CB at this precise moment.


Molly has been a terrific agent for us twice -- helping us sell a condo in Crested Butte a few years ago and more recently helping us sell a 4-bedroom home. She has exhibited exactly the right balance of aggressiveness and patience with us and on our behalf.

Brad & Laura

Molly was knowledgeable of the area and she stuck with us to get our condo sold. If we ever are looking for property in the future in the Crested Butte area we would call on her.


I have known Molly for many years, first in the Property Management field, and more recently in Real Estate Sales. I have always felt I could trust her to tell me the truth and treat me fairly.


Molly was the second realtor we engaged to sell our home. Our first real offer turned into a challenging deal where things did not proceed smoothly because of the buyer. Molly hung in there through the twists and turns, getting to the brink of closing, putting it back on the market when the deal fell through, and then re-assembling Humpty-Dumpty to finally make it happen with those same buyers. She gave us good counsel throughout and always handled our side of the transaction cleanly. Thanks Molly!

Dave & Ellyn

This is an excellent agent, I was one until 2007 for 36 years. We had a really small value lot to sell in bad time and she hung in there and sent me market information about what was going on almost every month.

Sandy Williamson

Molly was great to work with! She was always responsive and provided info along the way that left me reassured that my condo would sell at the selected price. Thanks Molly!


We've used Molly on two transactions and she closed a deal with some good friends of ours too and we are very happy with her real-estate skills. We've bought two houses through her and are currently trying to sell one of them. I highly recommend Molly and her company Red Lady Realty!

Bob & Steve

Molly is a true real estate professional and was instrumental in purchasing our property. Buying a property can sometimes be challenging but Molly made the process easy. Molly's knowledge of the market, recommendations on the steps to follow throughout the buying /closing process and her answers to our questions and concerns made the entire process very efficient and enjoyable. We will use Molly again and recommend her to anyone looking at buying a property in Crested Butte

Jim & Gayle

We had a small time window, specific needs, and a very limited budget to purchase a condo in a rising market. If it were not for Molly's attentiveness we would have missed our opportunity to move to our dream location. Molly understood exactly what we were looking for and notified us of the place we now live in before it was even officially listed. We were able to make an offer the first day our condo was on the market and the rest is history. I would highly recommend Molly to any of my family or friends. Thank you Molly Eldridge!

Joe & Kelsey

Molly was the key to finding and buying our new CB house. My wife and I had looked at properties with Molly for three summers before really being ready to commit to another Colorado house. Each time she was knowledgeable, informative, and patient. She was always available and flexible. When we finally found what we had been looking for, Molly was great with helping to formulate a plan, decide on a reasonable starting point, and respond to the sellers in a fair and logical way. We trusted her insight and opinions.

Getting from opening offer to close and even helping with setting up utilities and some repairs was a snap thanks to Molly. I’m certain that buying a house from a thousand miles away would have been much more difficult without her. My wife and I both recommend her to anyone even considering real estate in Crested Butte without reservation.

David & Susan Light

We decided to list our Links Lane Condominium with Molly. Molly was helpful and professional throughout the whole listing process. Anytime we had a question or needed information, the follow up was always timely and complete. When the market was slow, Molly kept us updated on market changes so we could make the best decisions on selling our condo.

We received an offer and Molly worked us through it to make sure we maximized our return. This was a second home so coordinating was essential. During and after the sale, Molly made the paper work and closing process easy for us.

Molly did a great job, and we would recommend her highly.

Reagan & Kyle Kneese

We first met Molly when she worked with the property management company who rented and took care of our home. When she became a Realtor she communicated with us, but we decided initially to list our home with another agent. She was persistent, professional and helpful so eventually we listed our home with Molly. Even when the market was slow, Molly always kept us updated on market changes so we could make the best decisions on selling our house. Anytime we had a question or needed information, the follow up was always timely and complete.

During this time, we received a few offers and Molly worked us through them to make sure we maximized our greatest return. This was our second home and all of the owners were in different places, so everything took a lot of coordinating. During and after the sale, Molly made the paper work and closing process easy for each of us.

Bottom line, Molly did an outstanding job for us, start to finish !

W & P Rickards

Molly worked with us for over two years to find the perfect home for our family and budget. She exhibited tremendous patience as we continually refined what we wanted, as well as flexibility to show homes at a moment’s notice. Her knowledge of the local real estate market and genuine enthusiasm when we found the perfect residence made working with Molly a true pleasure. We could not be happier with our purchase. We love, love, love our new home.

Thanks Molly!

Torrey & Rosemary Carroll

Molly worked with us for 4 years to find the right house in Crested Butte. We visited and looked at property in each season of the year. Her advice was invaluable as was her knowledge of neighborhoods and the town. She guided us through the purchase and got estimates on repairs needed for the property that we eventually bought. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase in the Crested Butte area.

Wil Hamilton & Jackie Bird

Molly was absolutely critical to helping us find our new home in Crested Butte. Although we had identified all of the “must haves” we needed, we were buying from out of town and had to rely on Molly to identify properties to view during our short weekend visits. Working with Molly via email and phone was as easy as could be. When Molly suggested that we view one particular property, we initially hesitated because the online photos were pretty poor. But Molly persisted, and we ultimately decided to view the property mainly because we trusted Molly and her judgment. I’m so glad we did, because that is the property that we ended up purchasing!! Molly’s focus on our needs and wants helped her to identify a property she knew we would like before we even knew it, and her local knowledge helped us get it below the list price. Add to that Molly’s contacts with people in the local financing, insurance, and home renovation business, and she quickly became our “one-stop-shop” for all questions about the purchase and renovation of our new home.

We can (and have) recommended Molly to friends and family without hesitation. If you’re looking for a new or second home in Crested Butte, we highly recommend that you give Molly a shout.

Steve & Larry

We were looking forward to searching for a domicile in Mount Crested Butte for getaways with our family. Molly helped us navigate through the listings and showed us properties which matched our desires and stayed in our price range. We ended up with a great place to enjoy our time in Colorado and could not be happier with the service provided. Closing on a property across the country was difficult but she guided us through the process and followed up on outstanding issues. She has followed up with us frequently after the closing to check on our satisfaction and has pointed us in the right direction as we continue to explore all this great area has to offer. We appreciate her time and dedication to our search, but also to our happiness. Thanks for everything, Molly. We appreciate you more than you know.

Dave & Jenny

Choosing Molly Eldridge as our Realtor for the recent purchase of a Condo has given us the opportunity to work with a true professional. Molly not only walked – and talked – us through all the different steps along the way, but she also went above and beyond the basics by providing valuable information our lender would have failed to disclose.

Molly listened closely to our wish list of features, produced a variety of listings for us to look at (all of which within our stated target price range), and stayed flexible as we adjusted the list of features we hoped to find in a home. At no point did we feel pressured, coaxed, or coerced to a certain area/complex and we were given the time and space to discuss each listing at our own pace.

We are extremely happy with the condo we purchased. It is ideal for our individual needs and wants.

It has been a pleasure working with Molly, and we would highly recommend Molly to any family member, friend, or anyone looking to purchase a home in the Crested Butte region.

JD & Veronika

Dear Molly:

Thank you for your assistance with my recent property purchase. I appreciate the time, effort and persistence you put into managing this purchase. Not being too familiar with the area, and living out of town, I was able to rely upon your timely and accurate communication to research and understand what I was buying. And by your understanding and direction during the closing process, we were even able to close on the property one week early, beating a hectic holiday week. Despite being just one out-of-town buyer, I always felt that you placed the highest priority on this transaction, and took special care in seeing it all come together.

In addition, your strong and positive network with related professionals streamlined everything. Molly, you exceeded my expectations, and I can wholeheartedly say I would recommend anyone to you who is interested in buying or selling property.


Todd Wiseman